In commenting on the pros and cons of a research paper or news story the evidence is exactly what is required. There is a requirement to dissect the publication from top to bottom. This means establishing whether the research paper was reviewed by other experts prior to publication (called peer review), having an opinion on the reputation of the journal in this respect, assessing the reliability of the statistical data and so on. This is referred to as the weight of the evidence. In other words is the evidence strong or weak and why. This story, for example, is published in a reputable journal, the British Medical Journal (BMJ), but as we will find out later there are questions about the weak statistical analysis used to form the conclusion that white rice causes Type 2 diabetes.

How the science can be criticized is only one important aspect of this story. It is how it is presented to the media that is also important. Even though, as will be seen later, the newspapers face a barrage of criticism regarding reporting style we should not forget the responsibility of how the science is disseminated to the media. The website, healthnewsreview.org, which addresses these problems is well worthwhile looking up. It will point you towards some important ways to assess news reports about health issues. The publisher, Gary Schwitzer?s is specialized in health care journalism and for many years he has addressed the serious issues of how the media mislead the public in this area. On the ?white rice story? his website raises the obvious weaknesses of the evidence presented in the BMJ article but it also raises the point about why the BMJ press release regarding a statistically and methodologically weak paper should headline ?white rice increases risk of Type 2 diabetes?



































Fizzy Drinks and Fruit juice ‘The News story’
The News Story: Fizzy drinks and fruit juice cause Type 2 diabetes, opting for plain water might pre... more
Laser treatment for retinopathy
It always important when you are a diabetic to maintain good blood glucose and blood pressure contro... more
Diabetes and Cardiovascular Disease
Heart attacks and stroke are by far the most frequent cause of premature death with patients in diab... more
Nutrition and diabetes
In the past patients have been given a prescription called a diabetic diet with many foods banned. ... more
Kidneys and diabetes Kidney Disease (nephropathy)
Diabetes represents the commonest cause of kidney failure in the Western World, Normal functioning ... more
Feet and Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy
We often forget about the importance of foot care. But simply having diabetes greatly increases the ... more